2026 Shute Shield Season Review: Manly with Harry Fehily
Manly endured another frustrating Shute Shield campaign in 2026, with a young Marlins side showing plenty of promise but struggling to turn competitive performances into consistent results.
Former assistant coach and newly appointed head coach Harry Fehily believes the foundations are there for Manly to rebuild, but says changes both on and off the field will be crucial as the club looks to reconnect with its community and regain its standing in the competition.
Overview with Harry Fehily:
“I think last season was a new group, which has become too frequent a thing at Manly over the last few years,” Fehily told Rugby News.
“But this time around, it was a new, young group who hopefully are going to be together for a period of time.
“There’s a lot of guys in there around 22 or 23, like Joe Dillon, Billy Dickens and Ben Di Staso, who potentially are going to be around together for a long period of time.
“I think they went through a number of games last year where they’re going to learn a lot of lessons. They were in a lot of tight games and stayed in games for long periods of time.
“If you take the Eastern Suburbs game at home in round six as an example, after we’d just beaten Sydney Uni away, we were in the lead and right in the game for 72 minutes.
“Then one slip by a young guy in the back row leads to a try for Easts and we get beaten on the bell.
“I think there were a lot of those lessons they needed to learn, particularly the importance of staying mentally in games for long periods of time and being able to bounce back.
“That probably came out a little bit in round 18 when we played Gordon.
“We went out to an early lead of around 24–0 before Gordon ran us down early in the second half to make it 24–21.
“But for the first time that year, the boys managed to regather themselves emotionally, settle and push on to win the game.
“Earlier in the year, they probably would have fallen away and not been able to control the momentum of the game or themselves emotionally.
“I think that happened quite a lot throughout the season.
“When you lose some of those games early, it becomes very mentally fatiguing once you get into the middle of the year and don’t have many wins on the board.
“There are a number of tweaks that need to happen, not necessarily on the playing side, but more around how the club, coaching staff and performance staff are set up.
“It’s about creating an environment that allows those players to develop the behaviours that will help them in those situations more often.”
What is the focus at Manly between now and round one next year?
“I think there’s a cohort of young players who can now be part of the club for a sustained period of time,” Fehily said.
“There needs to be a lot of work put into them and re-establishing some identity around what they’re about.
“It’s probably about starting to regain some respect internally and in the community.
“Manly has traditionally been a big club over the last 40 years, but over the last number of years we probably haven’t been where we want to be.
“So it’s about getting that young group, who can hopefully stay together for a period of time, to reconnect with the community and start to establish what we are as a group and work towards that.
“From an overarching club perspective, it’s about looking at everything away from the football field and asking whether we’re doing everything at the most optimal level.
“Whether that’s physio, strength and conditioning, administration or general management, it’s about reviewing everything and taking stock of where the club has been for the last few years.
“There’s been a lot of changes across the organisation away from the football field, which will hopefully start to create a program that allows these guys to develop more high-performing behaviours.
“Then it’s about adding some calculated recruitment of a few senior guys into the group who can help the younger players understand the behaviours needed to start regaining some respect internally at the club.”
Which of your players do you think can crack on to the next level?
“I think you’ve got guys like Davea Teoteo, who’s been there for a couple of years,” Fehily said.
“He’s a hooker who played a bit of back row last year and was injured a bit.
“Ben Di Staso is a back-rower who was a Manly junior. He came through the system, went over to play Colts at Easts and then came back.
“He’s definitely got a high ceiling. He’s got the right attitude and approaches things in the right way.
“Billy Dickens had a good year last year and is growing into that, and the same goes for Joe Dillon.
“There are a couple of guys who put their foot forward in first grade last year and I’d hope they’ll continue to progress.
“There’s plenty of other guys, but those are three or four in particular.”
What are you expecting in 2027?
“For us as a club, I think it really is about trying to regain some respect, if I’m being honest,” Fehily said.
“Manly is traditionally a big club and has been going relatively well in the lower grades over the last number of years.
“But first grade hasn’t been delivering on what the expectation would be from the Manly community and the club in general.
“So for us, it’s about looking internally and trying to build a level of connection with the people we have at the club.
“It’s about building a connection with the community, re-establishing what we’re about and what our identity is.
“And then just getting back to the basics of hard work and trying to regain some respect across the community and across the competition.”
